906-228-9292 | 500 S Third St. Marquette, MI 49855
File a Claim Start Your Quote

Providing Insurance in Northern Michigan and the Greater Midwest for 90 Years

Protect the Greatest Assets In Your Life

Protect your vehicle, your home and your future.
Get a free quote online today or call 906-228-9292.

Coverage That Fits. Pricing That Makes Sense.

  • 10

    Our Agents have an average of 10+ Years experience

  • 90

    Years of saving customers money and providing top-notch customer services

  • 4.9

    Review Rating on Google

“Working with Alex at Elder Agency on both my personal and business insurance needs has completely removed the stress of wondering whether I’m properly covered. I have full confidence that my policies are dialed in, and if the time ever comes to file a claim, I know I’ll have the right coverage and a knowledgeable team to guide me through the process. Thank you for consistently providing competitive pricing and comprehensive insurance packages that fit our needs.”

Klint Miller

“After 23 year with my prior insurance agency, I was in need of auto and home insurance fast. I submitted an online request for a quote. I heard back from Julie in less than two hours, and in less than 24 hours Julie at Elder Agency had me set up with progressive insurance for my car and saved me $100 a month. She was able get my my home owners insurance policy done shortly after that. She took care of everything and left very little for me to have to do. She was so helpful and it took a load of my mind knowing it was done so fast. Here's to another 20+ years with Elder Agency!”

Gregory Bauman

“Jessica made the insurance part of a big move (across the country) so much easier. She was incredibly knowledgeable, patient, and quick to get everything handled.What took her a day (with GREAT rates) would have taken weeks (no exaggeration as my attempts to shop myself were over a week with way overpriced rates and not the coverage I was looking for). Thanks Jessica!”

Dawn Brooks

“The best qualities I have found with Elder Agency is their competence and professionalism. Kate in particular is very knowledgeable and works diligently to research and gather information required to give her customers complete data concerning policies and services provided, eliminating the need for multiple call backs. Pleasant, courteous, everyone there is great to work with. Let them do the work for you. They will look out for your best interests.”

Dan Farr

“Got a quote a few months back from Shelly at the Elder Agency. I am very pleased with the entire experience. I don't think I can recommend them enough.”

Hunter Sadler

“Shelly, Julie, Jess and Taylor are the best. It is wonderfully that I can be a seagull and randomly swoop in unexpected with no communication have my needs meet with clear communication and professional service without feeling like a pain in the butt.”

Jayson Dutiel

“Alex was friendly, thorough and professional. He asked all the right questions and I ended up with coverage for my business property that was exactly what I needed AND he saved me a considerable amount of money on the quote he obtained from a highly reputable insurer.”

Joe Constance

“Kate Nasser did an outstanding job of stepping through all my coverage options and providing me a quote that ended up giving me better coverage at at a lower price in comparison to my previous insurance carrier. She even took care of cancelling my old policies. I now have all of my insurance through Elder Agency – very happy so far! Thanks Kate!!!”

Christian Hansen

“Shelly has been a true pleasure to work with. She's gone above and beyond to help me sort out my insurance needs. I price compared between companies but ultimately chose Elder Agency in order to continue the professional services Shelly provides.”

Clare Mendelsohn

“I love working with Elder! They make it so easy to ensure you are getting the best coverage for great rates. Our consultant, Julie Cygan, would check on us, ensure we were still getting the best rates, and was also quick to respond to any questions or needs that we had. I highly recommend working with this agency for all your insurance coverage needs!”

Rebecca Flitton

Top Rated Agency

We pride ourselves on offering the best insurance options and delivering exceptional customer service — all tailored to meet your unique needs.

Insurance FAQs

Questions about insurance? Start here.

Insurance Insights

We Pride Ourselves on Being Insurance Experts

Auto Insurance

What Really Determines Your Auto Insurance Rates?
Auto Insurance

Understanding Non-Renewals and Cancellations in Home and Auto Insurance
Auto Insurance

Mini Tort
Auto Insurance

Understanding Gap Coverage: What Every Driver Should Know
View All Insights
Built on Service, Not Sales

Since 1936, what matters to you, matters to us. Your home, your family, your business, your future — protecting it isn’t just our job. It’s our responsibility and our privilege.

Meet Our Team